R&D
Economics of MSAR TM vs. Natural Gas
1,000
800
• MSAR TM increases IRR by 6. 7
percentage points (2.5 SOR)
• As SOR increases, the economic
advantage of MSAR TM increases
NPVBT (C$millions)
600
400
200
ILLUSTRATION: Quadrise Canada
0
0.0%
-200
Natural Gas @ 2.5 SOR
MSAR @ 2.5 SOR
Natural Gas @ 3.0 SOR
MSAR @ 3.0 SOR
NG IRR
@ 2.5 SOR
MSAR IRR
@ 3.0 SOR
MSAR IRR
@ 2.5 SOR
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
8.0%
10.0%
Discount Rate
12.0% 14.0% 16.0%
-400
Note: McDaniel “SAGD Feasibility Study: MSAR TM vs. Natural Gas” dated November, 2005
McDaniel WTI price forecast; bitumen price = 40% of WTI price; 6:1 oil:gas pricing
RECLAMATION
Brush Mulching
Lease Water Pump-off
Restoration
Remediation
Land Reclamation
Reclamation Products
Spill Cleanup &
Recovery
Erosion Control &
Installation
Labour Crews
Lease / Road Mowing
Weed Spraying
Topsoil /
Contaminated
Services
Snow Plowing &
Towing
Rubber Tired Hoe
Fence Construction
Fence Removal
Grass Seeding
Pipeline R.O. W.
Cleanup
Authorized Distributor of Applied Geo-Environmental Solutions Inc.
C.O.R. Certified
GEOTEXTILES, GEOGRIDS, unwoven, custom sewn, high strength
CONTAINMENT LINERS - prefabricated custom sizes
EROSION CONTROL - silt fence & traps, drainage, dust control
TOLL FREE: 1-866-635-2442
Randy Ambler
Field Supervisor
Box 26 Mallaig, AB T0A 2K0
PH: (780) 210-1499 / FAX: (780) 635-2442
Total, with partner ConocoPhillips, is
also looking at possible fuel alternatives
to natural gas for the companies’
Surmont SAGD facility, says Cartwright.
Phase one production is scheduled to
start later this year at about 30,000 barrels per day.
Besides Total and Quadrise, three
other major oilsands players backed the
MSAR pilot at Joslyn: ConocoPhillips,
Paramount Resources, and Petro-Canada.
Quadrise, in developing MSAR, didn’t
go it alone, either. The company lists
several strategic partners, including
Akzo Nobel nv, a Netherlands-based
chemical company that holds patents
on the surfactant chemistry used in
MSAR. Quadrise Canada is the sole
licensee from Akzo Nobel for the
MSAR technology in Canada.
The MSAR technology can use feedstocks that range from minus 10 to
plus 14 degrees API. MSAR has been
combustion tested at the CANMET
facility at the National Research Council
in Ottawa. About 15 feedstocks have
been successfully tested for combustion
and stability with MSAR. These include
commercial asphalt, Lloydminster heavy
oil, Cold Lake and Athabasca bitumen,
upgrader and refinery vacuum residues,
and asphaltene bottoms (with bitumen), according to a recent Quadrise
presentation.
Adaptability appears central to
MSAR technology—and the Quadrise
approach to it.
“The type of bitumen [used] affects
the process enough to change cost
points and how we manufacture the
emulsion,” says Lennox. “We have a
lab here [in Calgary], so we can assess
[the feedstock] within a week or so,
and assess what it will take to emulsify
and turn into fuel.”
Noting that many oilsands producers
are using once-through steam generators,
Lennox says the emulsion characteristics
can be adjusted to specific boiler-type
requirements.
“We can custom-make a stable emulsion that lasts for a specific time, and
make it with different chemical, combusting, cost, and stability characteristics.”
He adds that Quadrise also works
with boiler and burn systems manufacturers to optimize boiler design to best
accommodate the emulsion fuel.